A Taxonomy of Response Strategies to Toxic Online Content: Evaluating the Evidence (arXiv)

In order to analyze the diverse range of counterspeech and counternarrative responses used by people, organizations, and language models, the current article defines toxic online content as digital message that is harmful to productive public conversation. The authors introduce the term Online Discourse Engagement (ODE) and offer a taxonomy that includes 25 different strategies, from humor and empathy to fact-based rebuttals, grouped into five broad categories: informational correction, speaker engagement, value alignment, victim support, and distraction. The paper offers a systematic review and meta-analysis to define conceptual limits and improve evidence-based practice in promoting healthier online conversation. It also criticizes the existing literature for its erratic assumptions and lack of evaluative rigor.

https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.09921